In Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 shown in the figures, 𝑅�=1 Ω, 𝑅�=2Ω and 𝑅�=3 Ω. � �� and 𝑃� are the power dissipations in Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 when the switches S1 and S2 are in open conditions, respectively. � ��and 𝑄� are the power dissipations in Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 when the switches S1 and S2 are in closed conditions, respectively. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct? (A) When a voltage source of 6 𝑉 is connected across A and B in both circuits, 𝑃�<𝑃�. (B) When a constant current source of 2 𝐴𝑚𝑝 is connected across A and B in both circuits, 𝑃�>𝑃�. (C) When a voltage source of 6 𝑉 is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, 𝑄�>𝑃�. (D) When a constant current source of 2 𝐴𝑚𝑝 is connected across A and B in both circuits, � ��<𝑄�.


 Alright, let's tackle this problem step by step. We have two circuits, Circuit-1 and Circuit-2, with resistors 

R1=1ΩR2=2Ω, and R3=3Ω. There are switches S1 and S2 in each circuit that can be open or closed, affecting the power dissipation in the circuits. We need to analyze the power dissipations P and Q under different conditions and determine which of the given statements (A) through (D) are correct.

Understanding the Circuits

First, let's visualize the circuits based on the description. Since the actual figures aren't provided, I'll make reasonable assumptions based on typical circuit configurations involving switches and resistors.

Assumed Configurations:

  • Circuit-1:

    • When S1 is open: Maybe R1 and R2 are in series.

    • When S1 is closed: Perhaps R3 is added in parallel or series, changing the total resistance.

  • Circuit-2:

    • When S2 is open: Possibly R2 and R3 are in series.

    • When S2 is closed: Maybe R1 is added in some configuration, altering the total resistance.

However, without the exact figures, it's challenging. Let's assume a common setup where:

  • In Circuit-1:

    • Open S1: R1 and R2 in series.

    • Closed S1: R3 is connected in parallel to R2, making R2 and R3 parallel, then in series with R1.

  • In Circuit-2:

    • Open S2: R2 and R3 in series.

    • Closed S2: R1 is connected in parallel to R2, making R1 and R2 parallel, then in series with R3.

This is a guess; the actual configurations might differ. For the sake of proceeding, let's proceed with these assumptions. If the actual configurations are different, the answers would change accordingly.

Calculating Resistances in Different States

Circuit-1:

  1. S1 Open:

    • R1 and R2 in series.

    • Total resistance, RP1=R1+R2=1+2=3Ω.

  2. S1 Closed:

    • R2 and R3 in parallel, then in series with R1.

    • Parallel combination: 1Rparallel=1R2+1R3=12+13=56.

    • Rparallel=65Ω.

    • Total resistance, RQ1=R1+Rparallel=1+65=115Ω.

Circuit-2:

  1. S2 Open:

    • R2 and R3 in series.

    • Total resistance, RP2=R2+R3=2+3=5Ω.

  2. S2 Closed:

    • R1 and R2 in parallel, then in series with R3.

    • Parallel combination: 1Rparallel=1R1+1R2=11+12=32.

    • Rparallel=23Ω.

    • Total resistance, RQ2=Rparallel+R3=23+3=113Ω.

Power Dissipation Calculations

Power dissipation in a resistor (or circuit) can be calculated using:

  • For a voltage source: P=V2R.

  • For a current source: P=I2R.

Let's evaluate each statement.

Statement (A): 6V voltage source, P1<P2.

  • P1 (Circuit-1, S1 open): 623=363=12W.

  • P2 (Circuit-2, S2 open): 625=365=7.2W.

Is 12<7.2? No, 12>7.2. So, (A) is incorrect.

Statement (B): 2A current source, P1>P2.

  • P1I2RP1=22×3=4×3=12W.

  • P2I2RP2=4×5=20W.

Is 12>20? No, 12<20. So, (B) is incorrect.

Statement (C): 6V in Circuit-1, Q1>P1.

  • P1363=12W (as above).

  • Q1 (Circuit-1, S1 closed): 3611/5=36×511=1801116.36W.

Is 16.36>12? Yes. So, (C) is correct.

Statement (D): 2A current source in both, P2<Q2.

  • P24×5=20W (as above).

  • Q2 (Circuit-2, S2 closed): I2RQ2=4×113=44314.67W.

Is 20<14.67? No, 20>14.67. So, (D) is incorrect.

Re-evaluating Circuit Assumptions

Wait a minute, I think I might have made incorrect assumptions about the circuit configurations. Maybe the switches bypass resistors when closed, changing the circuit topology differently. Let me reconsider the possible configurations.

Alternative Assumption:

  • Circuit-1:

    • Open S1: All resistors in some configuration, say R1 and R2 in series.

    • Closed S1: Maybe S1 shorts R2, leaving only R1.

  • Circuit-2:

    • Open S2: R2 and R3 in series.

    • Closed S2: S2 shorts R3, leaving only R2.

Let's try this:

Circuit-1:

  1. S1 Open: R1 and R2 in series: RP1=3Ω.

  2. S1 Closed: R2 is shorted, only R1RQ1=1Ω.

Circuit-2:

  1. S2 Open: R2 and R3 in series: RP2=5Ω.

  2. S2 Closed: R3 is shorted, only R2RQ2=2Ω.

Now recalculate powers.

Statement (A): 6V, P1<P2.

  • P1=363=12W.

  • P2=365=7.2W.

Is 12<7.2? No. So (A) incorrect.

Statement (B): 2A, P1>P2.

  • P1=4×3=12W.

  • P2=4×5=20W.

Is 12>20? No. So (B) incorrect.

Statement (C): 6V in Circuit-1, Q1>P1.

  • P1=12W.

  • Q1=361=36W.

Is 36>12? Yes. So (C) correct.

Statement (D): 2A in both, P2<Q2.

  • P2=20W.

  • Q2=4×2=8W.

Is 20<8? No. So (D) incorrect.

This also leads to only (C) being correct.

Given that in both assumptions, only (C) is correct, it's likely the right answer. However, since the exact circuit configurations aren't provided, there's some ambiguity. But based on standard interpretations, (C) seems consistently correct.

Final Answer

After carefully analyzing both possible circuit configurations, the only statement that is consistently correct is:

(C) When a voltage source of 6 𝑉 is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, 𝑄�>𝑃�.

Therefore, the correct choice is:

\boxed{C}

0 Comments

Post a Comment

Post a Comment (0)

Previous Post Next Post